Home>Software and Apps>Google Authenticator, Authy and Aegis Compared
Software and Apps
Google Authenticator, Authy and Aegis Compared
Modified: 19 November 2026
Table of Contents
You should pick Aegis if you care about keeping control of your own data. Aegis v3.0+ gives you local encrypted backups with AES-256-GCM, open-source code you can audit, and zero dependence on a phone number or cloud account. It costs nothing, has no ads, and no in-app purchases.

Google Authenticator: The Minimalist Option
Google Authenticator v5.0+ now includes cloud backup. It requires a Google Account and stores your codes there. That backup is not end-to-end encrypted. Google holds the key.
The app generates time-based one-time passwords (TOTP). There is no PIN lock, no fingerprint support, no desktop client. You get a clean interface with a search bar.
Transferring to a new phone used to be a problem. Now you can export all codes at once via a QR code. Scan that code on your new device, and you are done. You can also export individual accounts one at a time.
Your only lock is your phone screen lock. If someone unlocks your phone, they see all your 2FA codes. There is no app-level security.
Price: Free. No in-app purchases. Version 5.0+ is current as of 2026.
Authy: The Cloud-Backup Workhorse
Authy v24.15+ encrypts your tokens with AES-256 before they leave your phone. The encryption key is derived from your password. Authy cannot read your tokens.
You tie everything to your phone number. When you install Authy on a new device, it sends you a verification code via SMS or voice call. That is the only way in.
Authy offers a desktop app for Windows, Mac, and Linux. You can access your codes on your computer without having your phone nearby. That is unique among these three.
You can set an app PIN (4 to 8 digits). You can also enable fingerprint or face unlock. This keeps your codes safe even if someone borrows your unlocked phone.
Authy does not let you export your tokens to any other app. Not to Google Authenticator. Not to Aegis. Not via QR code. If you commit to Authy, you commit for good, unless you manually re-add each account.
Price: Free for individuals. Multi-device support only costs money under Authy's team plan (paid, billed per user). No in-app purchases.
Aegis: The Privacy-Focused Power Tool
Aegis v3.0+ is open source. You can inspect every line of its code on GitHub. It has no cloud, no phone number requirement, and no tracking.
Backups are local. You choose where to save them: your phone storage, a file manager, or a cloud sync folder like Google Drive, iCloud, or Dropbox. The backup file is encrypted with AES-256-GCM. You create a password. Nobody else can open it.
The app supports TOTP and HOTP (HMAC-based one-time passwords). You can organize codes into groups, search, and tap and hold an entry to see a QR code for exporting that single account.
Security is granular. You can lock the app with your phone's biometrics or a custom password. You can set auto-lock timers from 15 seconds to never. You can enable a screen cover that hides codes from prying eyes on public transport.
Importing codes is straightforward. Aegis reads Google Authenticator exports via QR code or a file. It can also import from Authy, but that requires a third-party tool called authy-to-aegis (a Python script available on GitHub). That tool only works if you have access to Authy's export function, which Authy removed in recent versions. You may need to use an older Authy desktop client or a workaround.
Price: Free. No in-app purchases. No ads. Current version is 3.0+.
How They Handle Account Recovery
Losing your phone is the real test. Here is what happens with each app.
Google Authenticator: If you enabled v5.0 cloud backup, you sign into your Google Account on the new phone and restore codes. If you did not enable it, you lose everything. The backup is not encrypted, so Google can read your tokens.
Authy: You install the app, enter your phone number, and receive a verification code via SMS. Then you enter your master password. Your encrypted tokens download from Authy's servers. You are back in minutes. You must have access to your phone number. If you lose your number or cannot receive SMS, you need a pre-configured recovery method through Authy's support.
Aegis: You install the app. You open your encrypted backup file from wherever you saved it. You enter your password. Done. You own the backup. You can save it in multiple places. No phone number. No cloud account. If you lose the backup file and your phone, you lose everything.
Which One Should You Pick?
Pick Google Authenticator if you only have one Google device and you trust Google with your 2FA data. It works. It syncs. It is simple. But there is no app lock and no encryption on the backup.
Pick Authy if you want codes on your laptop as well as your phone. The encrypted cloud backup and multi-device access are strong. The inability to export is a real trade-off. If you later want to leave Authy, you will manually re-add every account. I would only choose Authy if I had no intention of ever switching.
Pick Aegis if you control your own security. The encrypted local backups are yours alone. The code is auditable. There is no cloud, no phone number, no vendor lock-in. You can import from Google Authenticator easily. You can import from Authy with some effort. You cannot export from Aegis into either of the others, but you can export individual accounts as QR codes if you ever need to. This is my pick for anyone who wants full ownership of their 2FA.
How to Import Codes Into Each App
Into Google Authenticator: Only accepts manual account setup or built-in QR scanning from other apps that offer a QR export. No direct file import from Authy or Aegis.
Into Authy: Only accepts manual account setup by entering the secret key or scanning the 2FA QR code on the service's website. No file import from Google Authenticator or Aegis.
Into Aegis: Open the app, tap the plus icon, choose Import. You can import from Google Authenticator by scanning the QR code it shows during export, or by selecting the exported file. For Authy, you use the third-party authy-to-aegis tool to convert your Authy backup into a format Aegis can read. That tool runs on a computer and requires some command-line comfort. If you are not technical, you will manually add each Authy account into Aegis.
Part of our guide to Two-Factor Authentication, Properly Set Up.





